If you want to receive the latest news as soon as possible, sign up for our newsletter.

So, which messenger is the safest after all?

一番安全なメッセンジャーって結局どれなの?

“So, which messenger is the safest?”

We get asked this question a lot.

I completely understand why.

You hear names like LINE, WhatsApp, Telegram, and Signal, but many people have probably never seen a clear answer about which one is truly strong on privacy.

Just this March, a feature that uses Meta AI to organize chat histories rolled out more widely on WhatsApp, which is run by Meta, and sparked some debate.
Some have even suggested that WhatsApp could be a spy app that isn’t even encrypted.

It is convenient, but since interactions with AI are processed outside the end-to-end encryption between users, concerns have been raised that it is hard to tell how the content shared there is stored and used.

You might think encryption means you’re safe, but the systems behind it are surprisingly complicated.

So, which messengers are highly rated among privacy-conscious users?

Let’s take a look at them in ranking-style order.

 

First, the best-known option and an easy recommendation for pretty much everyone is Signal.

 

Only the sender and recipient can read the contents of messages, and users also appreciate that it’s run by a nonprofit organization.

In 2024, it introduced PQXDH, a post-quantum cryptographic key exchange method, designed to make it difficult to decrypt today’s communications retroactively, even after quantum computers arrive.

It’s a safeguard against so-called “harvest now, decrypt later” attacks, where communications are recorded now and decrypted ten years later.

That’s impressive.

Signal does have one weakness, if you can call it that: your phone number.

 

A phone number is required to sign up, so users are linked to their phone numbers.

 

In other words, while the contents of communications are protected, the fact that you’re communicating is harder to hide.

 

One app that has been steadily gaining support lately is SimpleX.

 

Its biggest distinguishing feature is that it has no user ID at all.

You don’t need a phone number, email address, or username.

To start communicating with someone, you just exchange a QR code or invitation link once, and then you can keep chatting anonymously.

The system is designed so that even metadata showing who is talking to whom isn’t retained on the server.

It also includes post-quantum cryptography, and privacy guide sites have increasingly rated it higher than Signal in their overall rankings.

 

Another name worth mentioning is Molly.

 

It’s a fork of Signal and a popular choice in the GrapheneOS community.

When you browse the official forums, you’ll find that there was a heated discussion about the differences between Molly and Signal just the other day.

Molly’s strengths include the ability to further encrypt Signal’s database with a passphrase,

erase traces from memory when you close the app, and receive notifications through a system called UnifiedPush without Google services.

At the same time, people have shared more measured opinions that whether you need all that depends on how you use it, and it’s educational just to read the discussion.

 

To sum it up, the go-to choices among privacy-conscious users these days are Signal if you just want something easy to use with friends and family, SimpleX if you don’t even want to reveal your phone number, and Molly if you want to harden Signal further.

 

By the way, AntiSpyPhone (Anti-Spy Phone) is a device running GrapheneOS, so you can install any of the apps mentioned here—Signal, SimpleX, or Molly—right out of the box.

Its profile feature also makes it easy to keep your everyday LINE and an anonymous app like SimpleX Chat completely separate, so it should be a good fit if you want to use different apps for different purposes.

Ultimately, which messenger you choose depends on who you want to hide what from.

If you first consider what you want to protect—just the contents of your communications, or even the fact that you’re communicating—I think you’ll be able to make good use of whichever one you choose.

The most anonymous messenger might just be an app you haven’t installed yet.


A little extra

As an unconventional messenger, one that works entirely on the web
https://privnote.com/
could also be an interesting option.

 

0 comments

Leave a comment

Please note that comments must be approved before they are published.